This article is based on a seminar by Greg Jackson called 'How to Defend Your Pro-Life Views', and adapts some of the key points raised in his talk.
Let me first make it clear that the circumstances in which a woman considers having an abortion are stressful and often difficult to cope with, and so people in these situations need much love, care and support to help them through. This help must come out of friendship and community, and cannot end when the pregnancy is over. Whatever happens, people need to know that they are unconditionally loved and will have friendship and support through all circumstances, be it abortion, miscarriage, birth and raising a child, or adoption.
This article is a logical argument for defending the rights of the unborn, but I realise that life is not usually logical or well ordered. It is messy and chaotic, and often we make choices that we later regret. Everyone in these difficult situations needs our help and support, regardless of whether they've had an abortion or not. No person can judge another's actions; we can only try, with gentleness and humility, to bring those around us to a place where they value the lives of the unborn. With this firmly in mind, I'd encourage you to engage with the rest of this article.
Ultimately, every debate about abortion comes down to one key question, regardless of the circumstances surrounding the argument or the nuances in the points made. Consider the following argument.
"My body, my choice"
You've probably heard this slogan quite a lot from people who believe that a woman has the right to choose to end the life of her own unborn baby. If the baby were a part of the mother and not a distinct human being, then it would indeed be her choice, just as it is your choice to have a medical procedure. However, if there is in fact a human being inside the mother's womb, then this argument does not hold. The unborn baby is not the mother's body or property, and has a right to life. People are not property.
The critical question: are the unborn human?
Simply put: if the unborn are not human, then it is acceptable to end their lives in any circumstance. However, if the unborn are in fact wholly human, then it is unacceptable to end their lives through abortion. So this is the critical question: do the unborn have the intrinsic worth and value of human beings? If abortion is wrong in one situation, then it is wrong in every situation. This is because of the incredible, infinite value of human life, and because the right to life is the most precious and fundamental right of any human being.
Are the unborn fundamentally different from me?
The debate should therefore focus on this critical question. We are all different on every measurable characteristic, yet we are still all equally valuable. Let's examine the ways in which the unborn are different from us, and see what we conclude about their humanity. These points have a handy acronym to help you remember them: SLED.
S: Size
Smaller people are just as valuable as larger people. Teenagers are smaller than adults, children smaller than teenagers, babies smaller than children, and the unborn smaller than babies. Clearly each is as valuable as the next, so why should the unborn be any different?
L: Level of development
There are many different stages of development: mental, physical and emotional. Each aspect develops and matures over time, and differs from person to person. Since we all develop at different paces, our level of development is clearly not what determines the value of a person. Take the example of self-awareness: there is a sliding scale between the unborn and toddlers. No line, not even at birth, can be drawn at which a person suddenly becomes self-aware. Clearly it is wrong to end the life of a newborn baby or a toddler on the basis of their relatively low level of development, so it must also be wrong to end the life of the unborn for this reason.
And who's to say that if today we decide that we can end the lives of the unborn because they are not as developed as us, tomorrow we won't say the same about everyone who is less able than us?
E: Environment
Nothing fundamental changes about a baby as he or she is born, only their environment. In the early stages of human development, the womb is the environment that we need to live and grow. Why should we discriminate against the unborn based on a particular, temporary need that they have? Consider a baby just before and just after he or she is born. Nothing fundamental changes about them, only their location. Since we agree that it is wrong to end the life of a newborn baby, it follows that it is also wrong to end the life of a pre-born baby, as they are fundamentally identical.
D: Dependency
If someone is dependent on you, then you have a responsibility to look after and care for that person. Indeed, the more dependent the person is, the more responsibility you have towards them. A parent and child are a good example: the younger the child, the more responsibility and duty of care their parents have. So it is with young babies and the unborn. Their parents, and we as a wider society, have an obligation to protect and care for them. Protecting someone's life is the most fundamental responsibility of any parent or guardian, so why should this responsibility not extend to the unborn, who are in greater need of protection?
So, are the unborn human?
None of these differences make the unborn any less human; indeed, they are just like us. Since we know that taking innocent human life is wrong, it must follow that abortion is also wrong.
As I wrote at the beginning of this article, it is not our place to judge the actions of others. Instead we should love and have compassion for all people, irrespective of anything they have done with which we may disagree. Women going through difficult pregnancies, abortion, adoption or the raising of children in difficult circumstances need our help and our time, and it is only through a persistent, servant-hearted love that people's hearts will be softened towards the unborn.