Past talk · Michaelmas term 2021

Personhood of the unborn

Professor John Wyatt · 27 Oct 2021

On 27th October 2021, we were joined by Professor John Wyatt as he explored the theme of the personhood of the unborn with us. Having worked as a neonatal doctor with pre-term babies from as early as 22 weeks' gestation, he was able to speak to both the medical facts about a foetus's development, as well as sharing his personal experience interacting with these pre-term babies and their families.

With respect to the questions of humanity and when life really begins, he challenged us to move away from purely scientific analysis of life and think about the issue in terms of philosophy and theology. So instead of asking "Where does human life begin?", we should be asking "When is there a person whom I have a duty to protect?"

This is especially important when we realise the need to acknowledge different tensions. There is tension between what the foetus already is and what it is becoming: from fertilisation, the foetus is already an embryonic human, and it is in the process of becoming a full-grown human. There is also tension between the physical and the immaterial: while the foetus is a bundle of cellular machinery, it is also becoming a unique and irreplaceable person. Therefore, there is a limit to our understanding of personhood if we consider only the biological perspective and forget the aspects of 'becoming' and the immaterial.

Having thought about these tensions, we were encouraged to think of the role of love in defining personhood. With anecdotes from his time in neonatal care, such as nurses paying special attention to those babies whose parents weren't present for whatever reason, or by pointing out how many parents start celebrating the coming of their child from the moment they know they've conceived even though all they have is an embryonic scan, Professor Wyatt challenged us to recognise the influence a loving perspective has on our definition of personhood.

Recommended reading

  • Matters of Life and Death, John Wyatt
  • Fearfully and Wonderfully Made, Megan Best
  • Ethics at the Beginning of Life: A Phenomenological Critique, James Mumford

All past talks