On the 2nd of March, we were joined by Heidi Crowter and her mother Liz. Heidi shared some of her experience of living with Down's syndrome, and why in 2020 she decided to take on a court case against the UK government for abortion laws which she believes are discriminatory to her and others with 'serious handicaps'.
Heidi began by sharing one of her favourite verses from the Bible, from Psalm 139: "For you created my inmost being: you knit me together in my mother's womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are wonderful."
Heidi then shared her story. Her joy and passion for life showed as she gently made fun of her family, talked about gaining qualifications and independence, and told us how she met, fell in love with, and married her husband James. Since 2016, Heidi has been working with the charity Don't Screen Us Out, working to change opinions on what it is like to have Down's syndrome, as she believes that people "should see the baby, not just a problem." Heidi was shocked when she found out that 90% of mothers choose to abort after a diagnosis of Down's syndrome. In 2020, she was also shocked to find out that the law allows abortion up to birth for 'serious handicap' (the law doesn't define serious handicap, but this often includes babies with Down's syndrome or cleft palates).
Heidi took the UK government to court, as she believes this law is discriminatory. The court case attracted a lot of public attention, and though the judges ruled against her, Heidi hopes that she has changed people's minds on this issue. After losing the case, Heidi said, "When Wilberforce wanted to change the law on slavery, he didn't give up, even when events didn't always go his way. And when the going got tough, he kept going and I'm going to do the same because I want to succeed in changing the law to stop babies like me being aborted up to birth, because it's downright discrimination."
Heidi's mother Liz then shared her own experience, and some of the statistics on ground E abortions in the UK. In particular, Liz is concerned that the way prenatal screening is conducted in the UK leads women to wrongly believe that a baby with Down's syndrome's life is not worth living. She described how almost half of pregnant women believe this screening is routine, and how of those who refuse, half are offered the tests again.¹ Though the RCOG (Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists) says in their screening guidelines that "women and their partners should be given the NIPT results and what they mean in a non-directive way",² one woman "was told I was being irresponsible by not accepting further tests".
This is just before a diagnosis. One shocking quote reflects some of the pressure facing expectant mums of babies diagnosed with serious medical conditions: "sorry, it's bad news, baby does have DS; I've booked you in for a termination on Thursday at 10."
These facts raise deeply serious questions about the way that we in the UK view disability and personhood. The abortion laws in our country contain neither a definition of 'personhood' nor of a 'serious handicap'. Though Heidi's work in disability activism and her court case have not yet succeeded in changing the law, she is hopeful that these issues will be brought to light and that the UK will realise the urgency of the battle against disability discrimination.
Since this talk, Heidi took her case to the Court of Appeal, which ruled against her in November 2022.
¹ Sharing the news: the maternity experience of parents of a baby with Down Syndrome. PADS, DSUO and DSRF UK research, April 2018. Sample size of 1,410 women. ² RCOG guidelines, 2 December 2020.